Colorado Senate Seat “Likely Democratic”

Roll Call has an early rundown of where the 2014 Senate races are ranked in order of competitiveness. Colorado is listed as “Likely Democratic” among the 33 Senate races, which puts Sen. Mark Udall’s seat well outside the top tier:

The early read from both sides is that Udall is in a strong position for re-election. Even Republicans concede that he has deftly positioned himself as a moderate on fiscal and social issues.

But the DNA of Colorado is a swing state, and midterm races are typically difficult for the president’s party, especially during a second term. Republicans fell just short of ousting Democratic Sen. Michael Bennet in 2010. Therefore, the GOP is optimistic and several names have already surfaced. The Republican who strikes the most fear in the hearts of Colorado Democrats is Rep. Cory Gardner.

Other possible challengers include 2008 Senate candidate Bob Schaffer, former Rep. Bob Beauprez and state Attorney General John Suthers.

Nothing new there (at least not to readers of Colorado Pols). Republican Rep. Cory Gardner is mentioned as the “scariest” potential GOP candidate, and also picked up a mention in a similar story on The National Journal (subscription required).

Is Gardner really “The Republican who strikes the most fear in the hearts of Colorado Democrats?” On the whole, of course not. But this is all relative to other potential GOP candidates, and with that background Gardner is definitely the one that would be most worrisome for Udall.

Gardner’s relative strength is key in this discussion, because Udall would still be a heavy favorite for re-election if Gardner was the GOP candidate. And that is exactly why Gardner won’t run for Senate in 2014. He’s doing the smart thing by letting his name float out there for 2014, because any discussion of Gardner as a Senate candidate only enhances his name ID and perceived strength among Republicans.

Gardner won’t run against Udall because it is too big of a political risk. He can hold his current House seat for as long as he wants, so there’s no rush to move up. If he did decide to run against Udall and lost, Gardner would be out of elected office without having had time to grow his political network (a Republican would likely replace Gardner in CD-4, which would preclude him from trying to retake his old seat in 2016).

Gardner is in a great position to be mentioned as a top Senate challenger, which is only happening because the GOP has no bench in Colorado. He won’t run, but for now there’s no benefit to officially removing his name from the rumor mill.

15 Community Comments, Facebook Comments

  1. MADCO says:

    Don Maes, Mike Coffman and Ken Buck.

    Ryan Frazier, and Jane Norton are a close 2nd tier.

    The Bobs? c’mon, you might as well have included Tom Tancredo and Hank Brown.

    Maybe the R’s will start pushing Udall for Secretary of State and go after this seat instead of MA.   Hell- maybe President Obama will give Udall a gig …. who is Hancock’s assistant? DPS Superintendant?

  2. Republican 36 says:

    In the past, Colorado has been a swing state but I think our state is now “Blue.” The Democratic Party won the 2004, 2006, 2008 elections here, stemmed the tide of the Republican wave in 2010 and then won another big victory this year. Based on that history and looking forward, Colorado is now Blue.

  3. caroman says:

    Chuck Todd’s “Daily Rundown” today focused on Obama’s results in Colorado.  They reported the current totals as: Obama 1,322,000 (51.5%) vs. Romney 1,184,000 (46.1%), a 5.4% margin of victory.  

    All the pundits on the panel noted that this was a significant, and surprising by its size, win for Obama and the Dems.  They pointed out that if the GOP cannot compete in states like CO, especially in the CO suburbs, then the GOP has real serious problems.  I couldn’t agree more.

  4. Craig says:

    There is precedent for him to come back and try to reclaim his seat.  Remember when Ken Kramer ran and lost the US Senate seat and then the next year came back and tried to off Joel Hefley?  Well, it didn’t work, but it was done.

  5. Tom says:

    The numbers will keep the seriously ambitious candidates away and won’t encourage much national recruitment. Left to their own devices, the state party is bound to do something wacky. If they could just recruit somebody sensible and not slaughter them in a primary, Udall could be beatable. The dude isn’t the kind of inspirational figure to really pump up the base turnout if the GOP has another big mid-term, especially if the GOP candidate isn’t insane.  

    This race will most likely feature a cocky ultraconservative Coors-type self-funder who will pour enough money into the race to narrow the polling and make for some good horserace theater.  

  6. kevidboyd says:

    Zippo lighters , vast range and same day dispatch possible . We can engrave your zippo for that special gift . We are a genuine UK company established 20 years .

    zippo lighters



  7. Lark says:

    The Republicans have a “secret weapon” candidate to run against Udall they are keeping very quiet.  They claim he is the triple threat because he speaks perfect Spanish (raised in Mexico I think), leads an aerospace industry association in Washington, DC (high-tech jobs) and is a millionaire.   Anyway I was told he was aksed to run against Polis but declined to jump in the primary against Lundberg and Weissman.   What I find interesting is he spoke to the Larimer County Republicans two weeks ago about getting the Hispanic vote and is booked at Rotary clubs in the Springs next month to talk about national security.  I am not sure if it is the same guy but there is also a Liam Weston (same name) who fought with the Angolan rebels in the 80’s and ran guns with Oliver North?  If its the same guy the shady past will hurt him.

  8. MADCO says:

    Dude- we cannot win if everyone knows thinks we’re blue.

    We need the crazy responsible part the R nominating procedure to give us the “best” opposition candidate to run against.

    We need the loyal and motivated base to update their registration and show up and not vote green.

  9. speedyexpress48 says:


    There were more votes for Obama in Colorado than in Pennsylvania (5.4-5.5% vs 5.0%.) Tho I think the numbers were updated for PA so the numbers are now even.

    Pennsylvania may not be exactly a liberal or “strong blue” state, but so far the GOP hasn’t really made too much progress in there.

    So to see Colorado, once a strong red state (and considered the ultimate swing state currently), beat out a somewhat blue state in blue votes, is (albeit pleasantly for me) shocking.

    I started to doubt that CO will remain a swing state long ago, but now I think that there’s a 75% chance that CO will be a safe blue state eventually. It isn’t that great, but I think the demographic shifts (plus a strong streak of social libertarianism) will eventually put this state in the Dem column.

  10. MADCO says:

    What does Nate Silver say?

    Or that polling company Bennet used that got 2010 so right so often.


    52.3      47.4

    So that would be more than 4, less than 5.

    by: MADCO @ Fri Nov 02, 2012 at 10:21:49 AM MDT

  11. Craig says:

    and then maybe Ken Salazar will come home and kick someone else’s butt.

  12. Danny the Red (hair)Danny the Red (hair) says:

    as the GOP frontal lobes examine the data and attempt to accommodate the growing demographic diversity of the country, I expect the GOP lizard brains to fight the rational part of the party and nominate reactionary candidates on immigration.

    Tom Tancredo 2014 (Senate or Governor)

  13. MADCO says:

    I kinda hope your right.

    But then, I am a Cubs fan, so the public humiliation and potential shame of being associated with a big LOSER has sorta washed over me and I just don’t care anymore.   I mean it’s not like I was so overcome with patriotism that I had to have sex with anyone. Oh wait…that was the other one.

  14. MADCO says:

    those crazy kids.

  15. Gray in Mountains says:

    I’ll bet we all will. Just come to the next gathering. Put a profile of a Russian pop star on it and Dave will buy a bunch of them

Leave a Reply

Comment from your Facebook account

You may comment with your Colorado Pols account above (click here to register), or via Facebook below.