Top Ten Stories of 2012 #8: Greg Brophy and the “War on Women”

Between now and New Year’s Eve, Colorado Pols is recapping the top ten stories in Colorado politics from the 2012 election year.

Two years ago, one of the closest U.S. Senate races in the country was decided, in some of the clearest terms we’ve ever seen, by women voters in Colorado. The record on women’s issues of Weld County DA Ken Buck, who narrowly defeated former Lt. Gov. Jane Norton in a bitter GOP primary, was the single most significant factor in Buck’s loss to appointed incumbent Sen. Michael Bennet in a year that otherwise trended heavily Republican. Bennet’s 17-point victory with women voters, overcoming many other demographics where Buck prevailed, has subsequently become a model for defeating Republicans in other competitive states.

As 2012 revealed once again, Ken Buck’s problems from 2010 are systemic and unresolved within the Republican Party. In the national and local political spotlight this year was a Republican Party intent on branding itself as overtly hostile to women, on a range of issues that most women no longer consider debatable.

A good example was provided, at the national and local level, by the response to testimony in Washington by a law student at Georgetown University, Sandra Fluke. After Fluke’s testimony in favor of contraceptive insurance coverage, nationally-syndicated radio host Rush Limbaugh called Fluke a “slut,” resulting in nationwide outrage. Colorado Sen. Greg Brophy jumped to Limbaugh’s defense as the controversy raged and Limbaugh issued a rare apology, saying he too doesn’t “want to buy your booze, pay for your spring break or your birth control.”

After Democrats and their allies put Brophy’s name up in lights, his colleagues in the Senate Republican minority held a jaw-droppingly absurd rally on the west steps of the state capitol, where they defended Brophy, and compared contraceptive insurance coverage to the Nazis, “mind control,” and (our favorite) King Henry VIII. Needless to say, this helped provide local Democrats with bountiful evidence to support their claim, without any hyperbole, that Republicans were waging a “war on women.”

By the time the presidential campaign was in full swing this summer, Colorado Democrats and allies were hard at work planting the “war on women” meme on the GOP presidential ticket. To some extent with Mitt Romney but especially targeting Romney’s running mate Rep. Paul Ryan, hard-line positions on abortion and contraception played a major role in alienating women voters from the Republican presidential ticket–just as was done to Ken Buck in 2010.

From Buck in 2010 to Ryan, Todd Akin, and Richard Mourdock in 2012, recent history is full of examples of conservative candidates brought to ruin by their unpalatable views on women’s issues. After this election, there was a brief attempt here in Colorado to downplay the significance of women voters–based on faulty information and, in our view, wishful thinking.

If Republicans in Colorado and elsewhere do not learn this lesson, and meaningfully change course, we see many more Ken Bucks in their future.

5 Community Comments, Facebook Comments

  1. JeffcoBlueJeffcoBlue says:

    You’ve got Brophy all wrong. What a charmer he is!

    I hope he’s what every women thinks of when they hear “GOP.” After Akin and Mourdock of course.

    Loving the brand. They are the brand and the brand is them.

  2. DavidThi808DavidThi808 says:

    Every single one said they would not trust any GOP candidate because of their policies on women’s health. Yes I live in Boulder but some of the women I talked to are Republicans (yes we have some here) who are upset that they feel required to vote a straight Democratic ticket.

  3. MADCO says:

    I got nothing to say.

    Just smile and wave. Smile and wave.

    I hear talk radio in the car – and not that much.  But it doesn’t take very long to realize they don’t understand why Romney/Ryan lost nor why they had such awful candidates in some other races.  They don’t really understand why Senator Warren won (hint: it’s not just because it’s MA).

    Untill or unless they ever figure it out – I will be smiling and waving.

  4. Pam Bennett says:

    Almost all women around here have the same view of the GOP.  What is interesting is how well Buck is known and used as an example of how to deal with the “woman issue”.

  5. Diogenesdemar says:

    that doesn’t fall into a swoon over a man who will protect her from marauding melons . . .

Leave a Reply

Comment from your Facebook account


You may comment with your Colorado Pols account above (click here to register), or via Facebook below.