Notable Links



Denver Internet Marketing by Parallel Path

Knowledge Messenger

Arvada Boutique Clothing Store Stella B's

Schaffer Shoots Foot on Major Human Rights Scandal?

by: Colorado Pols

Mon Apr 07, 2008 at 13:34:42 PM MDT


UPDATE: Liberal activist group Progress Now has more details on Bob Schaffer's 1999 trip to Saipan, including assertions that Schaffer's trip was directly arranged by Jack Abramoff's lobbying firm.

As the Denver Post reports:

Experts say the race for Colorado's open U.S. Senate seat shows the political difficulties of the immigration issue in 2008, especially in the West.

Still, the issue presents a more delicate balancing act for Republicans. Polls show it's a top issue of concern for GOP voters in Colorado but much less of a priority for key unaffiliated voters.

At the same time, the issue has played less potently for Republican candidates at the national level than many party strategists expected...

"To look for a pure way out of a big mess is just unrealistic," said Schaffer, who outlined his immigration views recently in an interview with The Denver Post...


All reasonable enough, even conciliatory given where so many Republicans have been on immigration. But then Schaffer stepped into an scarcely-believable trap, one he may spend the rest of this campaign season trying to explain away:

He pointed to the Northern Mariana Islands, a U.S. protectorate that imports tens of thousands of foreign textile workers, as a successful model for a guest-worker program that could be adapted nationally. [Pols emphasis]

"The concept of prequalifying foreign workers in their home country under private- sector management is a system that works very well in one place in America," he said of the islands' program...

We can't believe he brought up the Northern Marianas experience with immigrant labor as a good thing. Seriously, we're floored by this. You may not understand exactly what we're talking about yet, but by the time Democrats get through reminding you of the whole sordid story featuring Jack Abramoff, Tom DeLay, and forced abortions (you read that correctly) you will--everybody will. Some background on the "successful private-sector management" of immigration in the Northern Marianas from the liberals at Democracy Now:

Colorado Pols :: Schaffer Shoots Foot on Major Human Rights Scandal?
We turn now to [Jack] Abramoff's special relationship with the South Pacific island of Saipan and how it connects to his ties to House Majority Leader Tom DeLay. Saipan is an American territory in the South Pacific also known as the Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands. In the mid-1990s Abramoff was on the payroll of Saipan officials aiming to stop legislation that would crack down on sweat shop conditions, which run rampant on the island. In 1997, Abramoff arranged a lavish trip to the island of Saipan for Delay.

Most of the workers in these factories are from mainland China...

In fact, American authorities have discovered many Chinese workers are forced to sign secret agreements, known as shadow contracts, before they leave China, severely and, in some ways, illegally restricting their activities while on American soil. For example, in this agreement translated into English by American authorities, workers are forbidden to participate in any religious or political activity or to ask for a salary increase or even to fall in love or get married...

BRIAN ROSS: The bosses at the factory said they didn't want to talk about what they called ridiculous allegations. But human rights workers say it's common practice at this factory and others.

ERIC GREGOIRE: With 11,000 Chinese workers here, I have never seen a Chinese garment factory worker have a baby in my entire four years on Saipan.

BRIAN ROSS: There are no children in those barracks?

ERIC GREGOIRE: None. Inside that factory Chinese law applies, and Chinese law is supreme.

BRIAN ROSS: Even though it's the United States of America?

ERIC GREGOIRE: That's right. The flag doesn't fly inside there...

AMY GOODMAN: I want to go to the issue of forced abortion, which is astounding given Tom DeLay's stand on abortion. Can you talk about that?

BRIAN ROSS: Well, it's completely counter to anything that DeLay or most Republicans seem to espouse, that was, on that island there were forced abortions. And the workers there who are all young women, who often had to pay to get these jobs, knew the rules. And they were barred from having boyfriends and certainly barred from having children if they became pregnant. They knew where to go, and there were a few essential back-alley abortion mills on the island. And that's where these young Chinese women went in order to keep their jobs. And that was the deal. That's part of the situation that was essentially endorsed by DeLay when he fought the laws. The laws were established essentially exempting Saipan, although it is a U.S. territory, from U.S. labor laws.

AMY GOODMAN: So, of course, the clothing that is made there says "Made in the U.S.A."

BRIAN ROSS: Exactly right. They have the exemptions made in the U.S.A. Ralph Lauren, Tommy Hilfiger, all the major brands have garment factories there, owned primarily by Chinese industrialists from Hong Kong who brought in Chinese material. And the Chinese workers who lived in something akin to-I don't want to call it a labor camp, but it was surrounded by barbed wire. They were taken on the backs of trucks to these factories. They work 10, 12 hours a day, then brought back to their camps. An ugly scene there, one that was defended effectively by the garment manufacturers and by the government of Saipan at the time, with the expenditure of millions of dollars on Jack Abramoff.

AMY GOODMAN: You talk about how in a memo that ABC News got that Abramoff wrote to his law firm, Preston, Gates, Ellis (& Rouvelas, Meeds, at the time), that was paid $1.36 million by Saipan officials, said such congressional trips, talking about Tom DeLay, are one of the most effective ways to build permanent friends on the Hill.

BRIAN ROSS: Exactly what they did. And, of course, Abramoff has now admitted that he used these trips as ways essentially of providing favors to congressmen who in return would do favors for him on Capitol Hill. And it's not just Saipan. Of course, other trips to Scotland, to Moscow, to Paris, all around the world. Abramoff was a very friendly travel agent for members of Congress who wanted to go somewhere.

BRIAN ROSS: Exactly what they did. And, of course, Abramoff has now admitted that he used these trips as ways essentially of providing favors to congressmen who in return would do favors for him on Capitol Hill. And it's not just Saipan. Of course, other trips to Scotland, to Moscow, to Paris, all around the world. Abramoff was a very friendly travel agent for members of Congress who wanted to go somewhere.

AMY GOODMAN: BRIAN ROSS: Essentially what he accomplished was to stop legislation, which is easier to do than to get it through. He was able to block legislation that would have changed the labor and immigration laws in Saipan and made it illegal to have these kinds of contracts. You couldn't have a contract like that in Los Angeles or anyplace else of the United States where the flag flies. But you could in Saipan. That was the loophole they were trying to close under the Clinton administration.

And in fact, when people at the Department of Interior attempted to do that, DeLay actually tried to introduce a bill to cut off funding for that particular section of the Department of Interior, to stop them from essentially backing the workers' claims. And it became an ugly situation on Capitol Hill. And DeLay and others, but DeLay in particular, were involved in blocking the legislation and making sure that that status quo continued on Saipan.

And guess who went along in 1999 to 'check out the situation?' That would be Rep. Bob Schaffer, who has also taken thousands of dollars in campaign money from Saipan politicians linked to this same congressional squashing of human rights reforms. There are literally hundreds of stories out there on the Saipan labor rights issue, which subsequently emerged a key part of the Abramoff scandal.

What's really, really amazing to us is that we spent about 5 easy minutes searching up gobs of damaging information linking the Northern Marianas, Jack Abramoff, and Bob Schaffer. How much time do you think we would have spent doing the same had he used some other example, maybe a less shockingly dubious and counterproductive one? Perhaps one that didn't open a can of worms for Schaffer much bigger than the issue he was trying to depressurize by "making nice" on immigration?

Unfortunately for Schaffer, we'll never know.

Tags: (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
if the business about forced abortions is accurate.....
...wouldn't that make Bob Schaffer anti-choice in both senses of the term?

Bob's for sanctity of life
unless it of course conflicts with any corporate interests.

"Good judgement comes from experience.  Experience comes from bad judgement" - Jim Horning

[ Parent ]
Actually yes.
One of the best Pro-choice arguments is that as soon as you allow the government to make a decision on if a woman should be forced to carry a pregnancy to term, it stands to reason that the government would be allowed to decide that a woman cannot carry a pregnancy to term.

Those of us who are pro-choice think the government should stay out of the argument all together.

"But when I see a 9-11 victim family on television, or whatever, I'm just like, 'Oh, shut up!' I'm so sick of them because they're always complaining."  Glenn Beck  


[ Parent ]
What?
That's not one of the best arguments.  It's not even a remotely good argument.  If say "I think that the government should ...", and you say "But wouldn't it be awful if the government did the exact opposite of what you propose?", you haven't made a coherent argument.

"... politics has been divided between two types of people: those who want more people to vote, and those who want fewer people to vote."
- Sen. Kerry


[ Parent ]
"a free-enterprise petting zoo"
http://www.alternet.org/story/...
In short, the Marianas embodied many of the key ideals DeLay and other House Republicans were pushing in their 1994 Contract With America.

For Asian sweatshop operators, the Marianas became the Promised Land incarnate. Since the islands were officially U.S. territory, garment factories there were able to tag their products with the coveted "Made in the USA" label. No rules, no regulators, no inspectors, no health and safety laws. What more could a sweatshop operator ask for?



"It is hard enough to remember my opinions, without also remembering my reasons for them!" - Nietzsche  

[ Parent ]
This is so shocking
Forced abortions.

Chineese soveriegnty on US soil.

Sub minimum wages.

Slave contracts.

If you can not find something offensice on this list:  I question your sanity.

So this is Bob's plan for America?  Is he running senate or for a spot on the Gibbet?


Please, PLEASE let him stick to this...
CNMI is a nightmare underbelly of US human rights.  If Schaffer continues to hold up the Marianas as a role model for immigration policy, he's done for.

"I have come to the conclusion that the making of laws is like the making of sausages-the less you know about the process the more you respect the result."  -- Anonymous IL State Rep. circa 1878

This is really interesting
It's not like Schaffer talks about anything & everything and this just slipped out. He has said very very little and so this specific talking point had to be scripted.

Which leads to the question - what was Wadhams thinking? Not even the rabid right has tried to defend what goes on in the Marianas.

So why this example in his talk? It was done for a reason...

Amazon tax? Bad Idea!


He's a true believer
The comment wasn't on purpose in terms of getting ahead of a negative story, but it was no accident, either.

Schaffer is such an unabashed ideologue and partisan that he doesn't believe any of that horrible stuff was actually horrible stuff. Why? Because Tom DeLay and Jack Abramoff said so.

It's sort of Schaffer's internal "if the President does it, it's legal" mentality.

Where does Bob get his truth--from his ideology or his own lying eyes? Schaffer's long history has clearly and repeatedly answered that question. It's why he has no business being in control of any piece of government.

Non impediti ratione cogitationis.

"Some of the people that wanted to engage me in conversation appeared to have been the losers in the 'Are you smarter than Michele Bachmann contest?'." --Rep. Barney Frank


[ Parent ]
will history record this as Wadhams' '08 "Macaca Moment" in the Colorado Senate race?
   How exactly did this occur?  Is Wadhams out of town on vacation and left no one to mind his candidate in his absence?  Did Bob chew through his muzzle and actually get to speak?
  After all the hard work they went through to keep Shifty from saying anything of significance about anything to anyone anywhere to date, and then this....

New Moniker: "Sweatshop Schaffer"
Tom DeLay called CNMI the "petri dish of capitalism" or something to that effect.

One thing to point out is that workers were forbidden to go to church, because the managers were afraid they could use churches to organize.  

"It is hard enough to remember my opinions, without also remembering my reasons for them!" - Nietzsche  


LOVE IT!
I'm gonna get my t-shirt now.

[ Parent ]
Is it "Made in (sort of) America?


"Collective fear stimulates herd instinct and tends to produce ferocity toward those who are not regarded as members of the herd." -Bertrand Russell


[ Parent ]
*Zing*


"It is hard enough to remember my opinions, without also remembering my reasons for them!" - Nietzsche  

[ Parent ]
How is it....
...that so many Republicans running in this state can be so stupid?  I'm rooting for Udall and would love to see this take Schaffer down, but man.  First Coors, then Beauprez and now Schaffer.  Our State GOP knows how to pick 'em.  

Someone please give this to Peter Boyles
And let him run with it. And run, and run. At first I thought this was inside-the-beltway overkill, but after reading it through and seeing Danny the Red's pithy summation, this scandal looks like it has legs.

Abramoff junket. Slave labor. Forced abortions. Prohibition on marriage. Chinese sovereignty on U.S. soil. "Guest worker."

All that's missing is "Arbeit Macht Frei."  


It gets better...
According to the URL below, the governor of the Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands, Benigno Fitial, contributed $2,000 to "Bob Schaffer for Senate" in 2004:

http://www.newsmeat.com/fec/by...

Benigno R. Fitial:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/B...


That's rich!


"I have come to the conclusion that the making of laws is like the making of sausages-the less you know about the process the more you respect the result."  -- Anonymous IL State Rep. circa 1878

[ Parent ]
Menu

Make a New Account

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?





Advertise Here!
ads@coloradopols.com


Active Users
Currently 34 user(s) logged on.

Search




Advanced Search


Colorado Pols Network




















Stay home if you have flu symptoms. Visit www.cdc.gov/h1n1 for more information.


RSS 2.0



Pols Gets Mobile: ColoradoPols.com/mobile/

Colorado Pols is on Twitter: twitter.com/coloradopols

Email Pols


How to Write a Diary That Will Make the Front Page



Relevant Links

Back Roads to the White House

The Big Media Blog

Blog It Right

Blog For Growth

Blogometer

Colorado Capitol Journal

Colorado Center on Law and Policy

Colorado Democratic Party

Colorado Ethics Watch

Colorado Independent

Colorado Veterans for America

Colorado Legislature

Colorado Lib

Colorado Libertarian Blog

Colorado Media Matters

Colorado Progressive Coalition

Colorado Republican Party

Colorado Secretary of State

Colorado Senate

Colorado Young Democrats

Commentary Today

Coyote Gulch

CU Democrats

Curious Stranger

Daily Kos

Dan Willis-Rumors

Dem Notes

Democracy for Colorado

Denver Politics

Denver Post

East Boulder County Politics

Ed Stein Ink

Election Neutrality Now

George in Denver

Great Education Colorado

Head First Colorado

The Hotline Political Network

Left in the West

Liberal and Loving It

Maintain Educational Standards in Colorado

Mount Virtus

MyDD

National Journal

On Call

Peak Dems

Political Gravy

Politics West

Political State Report

Progress Now

Prometheus

Project Vote Smart

Radio Free Denver

Rocky Mountain News

Senate Guru

Slapstick Politics

State 38

Steam Powered Opinions

Square State

Stygius

TalkLeft

The Thicket

The Bell Policy Center

The Hypothetical Wren

ThomasMC.com

Toilet Paper Online

Ultimate Politics

View From a Height

Walter in Denver

Wash Park Prophet

Washington and the West

Western Democrat



Colorado Pols is wholly owned by www.ColoradoPols.com, LLC
webmaster-at-coloradopols.com
Powered by: SoapBlox