President (To Win Colorado)
See Full Big Line
(D) Kamala Harris
(R) Donald Trump
80%↑
20%
CO-01 (Denver)
See Full Big Line
(D) Diana DeGette*
(R) V. Archuleta
98%
2%
CO-02 (Boulder-ish)
See Full Big Line
(D) Joe Neguse*
(R) Marshall Dawson
95%
5%
CO-03 (West & Southern CO)
See Full Big Line
(R) Jeff Hurd
(D) Adam Frisch
50%
50%
CO-04 (Northeast-ish Colorado)
See Full Big Line
(R) Lauren Boebert
(D) Trisha Calvarese
90%
10%
CO-05 (Colorado Springs)
See Full Big Line
(R) Jeff Crank
(D) River Gassen
80%
20%
CO-06 (Aurora)
See Full Big Line
(D) Jason Crow*
(R) John Fabbricatore
90%
10%
CO-07 (Jefferson County)
See Full Big Line
(D) B. Pettersen
(R) Sergei Matveyuk
90%
10%
CO-08 (Northern Colo.)
See Full Big Line
(D) Yadira Caraveo
(R) Gabe Evans
52%↑
48%↓
State Senate Majority
See Full Big Line
DEMOCRATS
REPUBLICANS
80%
20%
State House Majority
See Full Big Line
DEMOCRATS
REPUBLICANS
95%
5%
November 04, 2024 08:16 AM UTC
21 Comments
The Politics of Election Success. Josh Marshall at TPM.
I am hoping and praying that the giant orange turd is in our collective rear view mirror tomorrow night. Enough is enough.
What is it Republicans and "conservatives" fear will happen if Harris, specifically, and Democrats, in general, gain power?
I ask cuz my hope is that the majority of votes for Trump are not necessarily people who like Trump, but people who fear Democrats. It's been about 20 years of Republicans telling themselves that they are the only True Americans and that us Democrats are evil, un-Americans so I understand that they feel fear toward us.
I can tell you my very specific fears about Trump and Republicans and support those fears with quotes directly from Trump and high-influence Republicans, but I can't figure out what Republicans actually fear from us.
My theory is that as George Lakoff explained, Trump voters are driven by the “strict father model”. So when their “strict father”, i. e. Trump and other political figures project their own worst impulses onto Democrats, their followers adopt those same beliefs and fears as belonging to Democrats.
Demonization of “others” outside the tribe (or cult) works particularly well. Another way of saying it — this is a case of appealing to, and conditioning of, the lizard brain of their followers.
Yeah I notice this a lot. Maybe it doesn't matter if their fear of Democrats is based on things that Democrats actually say and do? That sure makes it damn near impossible to counter though.
I think the fear comes somewhat from right-wing echo chambers that actually go back far before Reagan. If Commula wins, we’ll slide into Marxism. White people will become unemployable and unelectable. The southern border will become optional and we’ll all have to hablamos español. The wars on Christmas and Christianity will intensify like a WWII pincer movement. Elementary schools will turn your kids trans or gay.
But the echo chambers have to be funded in the first place. I think Musk and twitter are now providing a real-time example of how it’s gone over the past few decades. It’s worth the money if they can elect candidates who will lower taxes and reduce “red tape” like enviromental regulations. I’d almost say this part of the equation slides beneath the radar, compared to the wedge issues that get people yelling at each other.
So it's not just that Republicans are being fed unfounded fears from conservative media, it's that those who drive conservative media want less tax and regulation so they're using fear to get folks elected who will do that?
Yes! I think Doby also said it well with the reptile brain thing. You can bore people into comas with white papers and statistics, or you can awoken their fight-or-flight mechanisms. I've read quite a bit of Lakoff and will recommend him highly.
A quick Google search resulted in a USA Today Op-Ed by Nicole Russell (As a Republican, I bashed Biden. But Harris' far-left ideas scare me even more.), who, by looking at her other opinion pieces, looks to be one of those Republicans who is afraid of Harris.
Russell's "fears" in this are…
THESE are the existential fears that drive Republicans to vote for Trump?! I don't buy it at all. Maybe I need to use a different search engine.
Just try rewording everything in the pull-out quote:
"Inclusion and equality" = there's no place for you (white males) in tomorrow's America
"Eliminate private health insurance" = it's an attack on the private sector job creators, plus hardworking Americans will suffer a crippling tax increase
"Gun buyback" = an assault on the Second Amendment, plus we'll all be defenseless against tyranny
"Ban fracking" = how can our economy run when the sun's not shining and the wind's not blowing?
"Oppose police hiring" = crime will run rampant everywhere, like it does in liberal San Francisco
It's a good question, chickenheed, with a complex answer.
The ones in the Fox news bubble or the MAGAsphere fear the cultural boogeymen they are told to fear: teachers will train their kids to be gay or trans, transmen will take over women's sports, immigrants will receive $9000 of citizen – paid tax funds. Immigrant criminal gangs will take over the cities and rampage through the streets. Consumers won't be allowed to buy electric or gas stoves, nor to build homes with conventional heating systems. All new construction will comply with imaginary climate guidelines, and you will only get electricity when the wind blows and/or sun shines.
Underlying these myths, and giving them whatever credibility they possess, are the realities that white supremacy is dwindling as the "white" race itself is becoming a minority. Patriarchal power is also diminishing as women take political, economic, and social equality. With this, gender noncomformity is becoming accepted, or at least not an acceptable cause for discrimination and ostracism.
So much for the propagandized and the true believers.
The fear for those who are wealthy, or wealthier, is that those "less deserving" middle and working class stiffs will demand all their stuff, and they will lose economic privileges they currently enjoy ( tax cuts, access to better health, living conditions, education, possessions, prestige, etc). It's a zero-sum equation…shared wealth, or equality of economic opportunity, equals total loss, in their calculation. Hence the fear…of losing it all.
kwtree, your response sounds like fear of loss of priviledge and the turning of dislikes into fears are the biggest fears.
When someone fears their loss of priviledge, it tells me they are not treating underpriviledged folks well.
Republicans had 8 years of Clinton, 8 years of Obama, and 4 years of Biden to see how Democrats govern. So they know what they will get. Anyone who says but Kamela will be worse is rationalizing.
So what drives them?
First there is a large segment that truly do want the old days. They want white men in charge telling us all how to act. They want Christian religon in school. They want the government not telling us or protecting us for liberal ideas like equality. They want the government forcing conformance.
There is a great book, American Nations, that I highly recomend. In some of our cultures people believe they should do as the elites direct. In some poverty in return for minimal government involvement is a good trade-off. These people are a sizable chunk of the populace and they weigh things out very differently.
Second, there is a chunk that is racist, mysoginistic, and/or nihlistic. For them, they want someone who hates what they hate and validates how they view the world. And these are the fundamental values of these people and in a democracy they get a vote – same as all of us (no one said Democracy is a great system, just that it sucks less than all the others).
To me the big problem with this group is we have a ton of young men growing up alienated from society and they find their fellow bros in these groups. They don't see a future from themselves with a great job, family, etc. and so they go into this cesspool. We need to find a way to reach & help any of these we can.
Third, there are the single issue voters. If you believe that human life starts at conception, that a 2 celled organism has a soul, then abortion is the critical issue for you. If you believe that we will see the end days in the next 20 years, then strip mining makes sense.
Or a more pedantic note, there are people that are all about their tax rate. You can explain that Harris will double the value of your stock portfolio over the next 4 years, Trump will half it, and they still will vote on the possibility that Harris may raise their taxes 2%. People hate losses more than the celebrate wins.
And there you have it – 45% of the voters.
Also posted to Liberal and Loving It
I undertand why the various nationalists and mediocratists* (racists, misogynists, anti-semites, etc.) vote for Trump. It's all the people who are marking Trump on their ballots because they fear voting for Harris (or any Democrat).
Your answer seems similar to kwtree's answer. It's a fear of losing priviledge and turning their dislikes into fears.
* – "mediocratist" is a word I made up to describe people who think they're better than another group. White "supremacists" are not better than people who are not-white. They are, at best, mediocre, so I call them that.
Thanks, everyone, for your thoughtful replies to my question!
I'm back with my election eve predictions……
Harris wins the nationwide popular vote by somewhere between 1% and 2%.
The electoral college map looks a lot like 2016. Trump ends up with 302 EV's while Harris ends up with 236.
Differences from 2016: Trump takes Nevada from the Dems. Harris takes Wisconsin from the GOP. Michigan and Pennsylvania go for Trump with his margins of victory in each state being less than the combined vote totals for Cornel West and Jill Stein. (History repeats itself, the first time as tragedy, the second time as farce.)
The GOP ends up with 52 seats in the Senate, picking off West Virginia, Montana and Ohio. The new majority leader (probably Rick Scott) is under a lot of pressure to eliminate the filibuster so that they can enact the new president's
hit listagenda.The House ends up with 218 GOP reps and 217 Dems. This is where things get REALLY interesting. Remember how much fun it was when they enjoyed a four seat majority? The rule authorizing motions to vacate the chair remains in the House rules.
The CO delegation remains five to three with the GOP holding CD-3, CD-4, and CD-5, with the Dems holding the remaining seats.
Tomorrow night what I'll be watching is Georgia, North Carolina, & Florida. All 3 count fast and 2 are EST while Florida is also CST (the panhandle). So 6:00pm our time we'll start getting substantial numbers from all 3.
My expectation – Harris will win all the battleground states and we'll be on edge, possibly for days as every last vote is counted, in Florida, Texas, & Iowa.
Senate – in Florida, Texas, & Nebraska, also very close races for Senate. I think Brown will have a decent win in Ohio. I think Tester will lose but I'm a bit hopeful because the big issue there is now Sheehy hiding his medical records from when he was shot. So do we hold the Senate??? Who knows.
House – comfortable Democratic majority.
My "most annoying" Presidential election outcome:
Do I think this is likely? I have no idea what is likely.
How I came up with a narrower GOP House majority …..
There are five House districts in NY currently held by Republicans which could flip. Three of those will flip. Sadly, Mondaire Jones will not be one of those. He will be made to pay for his role in taking down Jamaal Bowman.
There are four House districts in NC currently held by Dems which could flip. Three of those will. Don Davis will probably hang on to his seat. NY and NC are a wash.
The Dems will lose the House seat Elissa Slotkin is vacating to run for Senate in MI. (Dems down one.)
The Dems will pick up one seat in AL and one in LA thanks to corrections of racial gerrymandering. (Now Dems up one.)
Dems should pick up Don Bacon's seat in NE. (Dems up two.)
Dems will probably pick off a couple of seats in CA (Duarte, Garcia and Steele may lose). (Dems now up five.)
Mary Peltola and Jared Golden unfortunately lose in ME and AK. (Dems up three.)
I'm curious to hear what Dave sees as "comfortable majority" for the Dems and how he gets there.
Your House evaluation is good. Mine is more general. I think this will be a seismic event. People (primarily but not exclusively women) are questioning how they’ve voted, why they’ve voted, the framework for their votes. That will not be just a Harris vote. That reconsideration means they will be voting to solve the problem they see. And that problem is not just Trump.
Which races will it be enough – who knows. But I’ll bet some very safe Republicans lose their House seat. Not just the close races but some who figured they have a lock on their district.
Or to put it another way, while I expect Jim Jordan to get re-elected, it would not shock me if he loses.
I wrote more about this here.