The Denver Post’s Shelly Bradbury reports, and it’s not something we can ignore:
The U.S. Supreme Court on Tuesday ruled in favor of a northern Colorado church that sued Gov. Jared Polis over capacity limits on religious gatherings, reiterating a stance the highest court took in a similar case last month.
High Plains Harvest Church in Weld County sued Polis and Colorado public health officials in May over the state’s orders limiting attendance at houses of worship to 50 people…
The ruling isn’t expected to have a major impact on religious services in Colorado because the state already lifted its limits on in-person attendance at such gatherings. Three Supreme Court justices dissented from Tuesday’s ruling because of that change, on the grounds the case is moot.
The state had already announced in response to the Supreme Court’s ruling against New York’s restrictions on attendance to worship services that capacity limits would not be enforced. But as Michael Karlik at the Colorado Springs Gazette’s political blog writes, the religious right activists who filed suit in Colorado were determined to get their very own ruling:
The attorney for Harvest High Plains Church, Barry K. Arrington, told The Denver Post it was not a certainty that capacity limits via health orders would never present another problem for his client.
“The state has in the past amended this thing willy-nilly, and there is nothing to stop them from amending it tomorrow,” he said.
Readers will perhaps know attorney Barry Arrington best as the counsel for Rocky Mountain Gun Owners in their failed legal fight against the 2013 gun safety reform measures passed by the General Assembly and signed into law by Gov. John Hickenlooper. Arrington also represented a Longmont charter school a few years ago who had snubbed their LGBT valedictorian like Jesus would do. Mark Hotaling, pastor of the strip-mall High Plains Harvest Church (photo above right), is another close associate of RMGO’s Dudley Brown and the related faction of the Colorado Republican Party.
Now for starters, once you realize that all this hullaballoo is over a restriction to 50 persons in a building as small as the one that apparently houses Mark Hotaling’s microchurch, it’s tough to objectively stay very outraged. Back in July, Karlik reports, Hotaling was delighted to announce his allowed capacity had been increased to 73–close to a “normal size” service, he said then, and if you ask us still way too many people to safely congregate in this modest little storefront. Sometime after that, Hotaling filed suit for twice that capacity…but who knows if they even needed it?
What this all boils down to, of course, is the new solidly conservative U.S. Supreme Court majority flexing as it overturns the decisions made earlier in the pandemic by a different Court. The winners in this case are Colorado’s hard-right usual suspects making up the unholy alliance of the religious right and gun fetishists, and this court victory is a consolation prize after a another disastrous election cycle for Colorado Republicans in general and this faction of the party in particular.
Nominally Gov. Jared Polis is the defendant in the case of High Plains Harvest Church v. Polis, but the real loser is everyone with an interest in slowing the spread of the COVID-19 pandemic. As we’ve said many times before the right in the abstract to do a thing does not make it wise, and politicizing public health during this pandemic has fomented popular resistance to common sense that should have never been allowed to take root.
But here we are. COVIDiocy is here to stay, and so is Amy Coney Barrett.
You must be logged in to post a comment.
BY: notaskinnycook
IN: Wednesday Open Thread
BY: coloradosane
IN: Not “The Onion”: Trump Taps Matt Gaetz for Attorney General
BY: DavidThi808
IN: Wednesday Open Thread
BY: DavidThi808
IN: Not “The Onion”: Trump Taps Matt Gaetz for Attorney General
BY: Ben Folds5
IN: Not “The Onion”: Trump Taps Matt Gaetz for Attorney General
BY: Genghis
IN: Not “The Onion”: Trump Taps Matt Gaetz for Attorney General
BY: JohnNorthofDenver
IN: Lauren Boebert’s Persistent Underperformance
BY: 2Jung2Die
IN: Not “The Onion”: Trump Taps Matt Gaetz for Attorney General
BY: Ben Folds5
IN: Not “The Onion”: Trump Taps Matt Gaetz for Attorney General
BY: Genghis
IN: Not “The Onion”: Trump Taps Matt Gaetz for Attorney General
Subscribe to our monthly newsletter to stay in the loop with regular updates!
"And when you pray, do not be like the hypocrites, for they love to pray standing in the synagogues and on the street corners to be seen by men. … But when you pray, go into your room, close the door and pray to your Father, who is unseen. Then your Father, who sees what is done in secret, will reward you." or something
^^^this^^^
Oh, I thought we're supposed to provide the preacher with a dozen Rolls Royces to prove his favor in God's eyes?
That’s how you can
have faithbe certain you’ve found an especially smart god — the one, true,omniscientDunning-Kruger deity.The earlier Supreme Court decision and this one are based on public health orders which were poorly drafted. They singled out churches for disparate treatment based on the research which found church settings were important points of community spread. I'm uncertain what was different in this case from the one announced as 5-4 in November — but it was nearly the same and resulted in nearly the same alignment of justices (this one lost one in the minority because of the previous decision setting precedent). Trying to distinguish and making a division of treatment between churches (bad) and
* bicycle shops (good in New York)
* casinos (good in Nevada)
* gardening supplies (good in Colorado)
is a violation of long-time First Amendment theory.
So, as a variety of commenters last month said, setting the orders based on neutral characteristics related to the public health purpose would not be impacted. So, x people in y amount of space would be fine. Limiting decibels of un-amplified human voices (to avoid the spray inherent in shouts and singing) would be dandy. Saying those NOT working cannot remain in a building more than 30 minutes at a time would probably work, too.
“My clients are all volunteers doing the lord’s good work, your honors.”
Bicycle shops and gardening supply stores don’t have folks shoulder to shoulder belting out hymns. Your mileage ( or SCOTUS’ mileage, since I get that you’re being an explainer for SCOTUS reasoning here) may vary.