Marianne Goodland of the Colorado Independent produced some impressive journalism this week when she managed to 1) Learn about a secret “constituent” meeting with Rep. Ken Buck (R-Greeley), and 2) Find a way to get inside the room at said secret meeting.
As Goodland learned firsthand, Rep. Buck is making some fairly bold assurances about healthcare reform efforts in Congress that don’t really jibe with some of the other GOP talking points we’ve seen and heard over the last week:
President Trump has said his administration plans to unveil a replacement plan next month, but Buck told the crowd that it could take several years to come up with a replacement. “We need to come to consensus on how much we’re willing to pay. We will leave some people behind, one way or another” either by charging too much or coming up with a plan that won’t cover everyone, he added.
He pleaded with the audience to remove from their minds the idea that the repeal of the Affordable Care Act would happen before a replacement plan is in place. [Pols emphasis]
The healthcare marketplace, insurance companies and employers will have a chance to adjust before the ACA is gone, he insisted. “The idea that anyone wants to disrupt the economy in that way isn’t true.”
Whoa! These are some pretty strong statements coming from Buck that definitely don’t jibe with paid advertisements in Republican districts promising that the GOP “has a plan” for healthcare reform. Says Buck:
This is most definitely not the narrative that Republican leaders would have you believe about Obamacare…but that doesn’t mean Rep. Buck is wrong.
You must be logged in to post a comment.
BY: 2Jung2Die
IN: Tuesday Open Thread
BY: joe_burly
IN: Tuesday Open Thread
BY: harrydoby
IN: Tuesday Open Thread
BY: Pam Bennett
IN: Tuesday Open Thread
BY: JohnInDenver
IN: Tuesday Open Thread
BY: JohnInDenver
IN: Tuesday Open Thread
BY: ParkHill
IN: Tuesday Open Thread
BY: 2Jung2Die
IN: Tuesday Open Thread
BY: ParkHill
IN: Tuesday Open Thread
BY: spaceman2021
IN: Lauren Boebert Picks Up George Santos’ Favorite Side Hustle
Subscribe to our monthly newsletter to stay in the loop with regular updates!
It matches with what some other sources have been saying, though. The fact is, Republicans have supposedly been trying to come up with the "replace" part of "repeal & replace" now for as many years as the ACA has been in effect – and they still haven't presented their plan.
Either that means it's more useful as rhetoric than as actual action and they haven't really been working on it, or it means the various factions haven't been able to agree on an actual plan. And they may never get to that point. They're far more likely, IMHO, to get to the point where the House Freedom (spelled "Free Dumb") Caucus threatens to shut down the government or oust Speaker Ryan if they don't get an immediate ACA repeal bill on the floor and damn the replacement plan.
Maybe Republicans are just following the Pelosi Rule? We have to pass it before you find out what's in it.
Physician heal thyself.
Right. It's not like the information was out there as we went along, or that drafts of the bill were available to be accessed. Or that some people from your side weren't readily available to throw out erroneous information on it like red meat.
Where do you get your insurance?
Put up or shut up.
Moldy is incapable of any intelligent dialogue, or even intelligent trolling. He's not smart enough for that.
That's why he acts butthurt over the idea of "paid protestors". He's pissed because AFP and other rightwing groups won't pay him to post his vapid suckitude.
Pretty sure Moldyanus's medical care is paid for.
It sort of has to be, if you're living in a "special" facility.
(No, he didn't do anything criminal. It's not a crime if the victims are hand puppets.)
Of course, you agree the Republicans in the U.S. House and U.S. Senate as well as President Trump have promised, thousands of times over, that they will deliver a replacement at the time of repeal that costs less and gives each individual more coverage than Obamacare. Its time to make good on your promise regardless of Congressman Buck's views or other members of the Freedom Caucus..
You mean things like the Trump Executive Orders? All two pages?
Does thou have a medication for Kyl disease (#notintendedtobeafactualstatement) Doctor Moderanus?
Look at the bright side – think of all the time he'll have to focus his energy on fighting our real enemy in CD4: the omnipotent Julesburg Jihad
Dr. Moderanus? I'm guessing he's board certified in proctology.
He's the Dr. Kevorkian of cogent thought.
Yes, loser boy, but according to you and your demented ilk, when Pelosi *allegedly* did so, you ranted, raved, howled, became rabid and spittle-flecked, declared it the most heinous thing a politician had ever done — it was the literal end of the world!!! You were apoplectic! You and your hate radio/hate media goons raged endlessly, whined relentlessly, pissed and moaned constantly, bayed at the moon, screamed and wailed from the rooftops…
And then your side did it, and it was all suddenly OK.
Do you see the little problem with that, you vile hypocrite bastard?
“so-called Pelosi Rule”: Hardly what happened with Obamacare, and you know it. There was much discussion in public on that proposal.
Moderatus…answer Park Hills' question. Enough, you worthless troll. Answer the question or get off the site…permanently.
You voted for Trump. You and he and everyone who was duped into voting for Trump by his and your constant lying is responsible for the coming shit storm. Your champion is a phony. So are you.
Hail, Victory!
I kind of liked Buck's honesty about the issue. Is it even comprehensible that the guy could be growing into his job? That is almost too incredible to wrap my head around. I'm waiting for someone to say it was an April Fool's article. Good writing and kudos to Buck for meeting with constituents who don't have that sacred suffix (R) behind their name.
Agreed. Having such a vile POS as the POTUS gives me a grudging respect for politicians that are at least in the same zip code as the truth. Similarly, having such a chicken shit Senator (looking at you Corey) makes me respect Senators Cotton, McConnell, and others that are willing to take questions, in person, from their constituents.
I clicked and read the article by Goodland. Worth the time.
Agreed – a good read. It begs the question, "why not just 'fix' what we already have?" I know. Rhetorical. They must erase anything the black man supported to keep the base happy. <sigh>
Did you see Boehner's comments yesterday where he said essentially the same think? Methinks some freedumb caucusgoers' heads exploded.
Yeah, very interesting…
I kind of wonder whose statistics he does find reliable…
I was at that meeting. Buck tried to fall back on the standard Repub lines about the need for "market-based" solutions and the meme that government can't do anything right. And when he quickly saw that these folks weren't buying his talking points, he backed off. Then I think he started to listen a little. I'm not convinced that he'll change his position on anything, but you never know. The arguments that participants put forth were very powerful. And as for it being a "private meeting", it was all over Facebook and lots of people knew about it. And that includes all three Denver TV stations who I know for a fact were tipped off about the meeting and didn't show up for whatever reason. It wasn't a circus, but it also wasn't church social. People were polite but very determined to make sure he left that meeting with a few things to think about. In all honesty, I think it was more effective than some of the out-of-control town halls that I've seen on the news.
Like · Reply · 2 mins
Market-based solutions…
What a novel idea! Wonder why no one has thought of that before…
Twenty-some odd years ago when Newt Gingrich and the Heritage Foundation wheeled out the precursor to Obamacare – as an alternative to Hillary-care (a government-run program) – they called it a "market-based solution" because it would make coverage available for everyone but work within the existing private insurance markets.
Obamacare is a market-based solution.
Or does he mean supply and demand. That doesn't really work in healthcare. If a life-saving cancer treatment costs $500,000, is that a fair price? Or should we create more supply of cancer treatments so the cost goes down to $50,000?
Healthcare markets don't function as a survival of the fittest Jungle-Capitalism.
Thanks, madmike. I do know it was on Facebook, but if you'll recall, everyone who walked into that room (sans me) had to sign in and be checked off an invite list. If you contacted Buck's office, you got told it was "invite only." I'm sure the TV stations were tipped, but the media was told "no media." I just decided to do it anyway and see if I could get in without too much trouble. I just sat in the corner and pretended to be a fly on the wall – no mean feat for me 🙂
I was on Rep. Buck's tele-town hall just now. He answered a lot of questions about the ACA with reassurances that pre-existing conditions would still have to be insured, and that kids could stay on parents insurance until age 26. After that, he was all about the "market solutions".
Buck refused to answer a caller at 7:47. She asked about right wing violence, neo-Nazis, white supremacists, American homegrown terrorists. What was Buck going to do about that? I thought it was a very relevant question, seeing that, in Colorado, ALL of our mass shooting incidents have been from white male homegrown citizen terrorists. (Holmes, Dear, Klebold, Harris, etc).
"Next question," said our slippery CD4 representative.
My question about how his support of Trump's Muslim ban and mass deportations is depriving farmers and meat processors of their labor force? Well, he never got to that one, either, although I did leave a message.
By the way – Buck did call his meeting in Castle Rock a “town hall”. And you thought it was just a constituent meeting.
Nice discussion folks. Thanks for the insights into what is going on in Northern Colorado.