Argumentum in Terrorem: Gardner, Beauprez Appeal To Fear

18 Comments

by: Colorado Pols

Rep. Cory Gardner (R).

The Colorado Independent's Susan Greene has a must-read story out today, discussing the late-game turn by GOP U.S. Senate candidate Cory Gardner to an overtly fear-based foreign policy message against incumbent Democratic Sen. Mark Udall:

WITH a week until this off-year election, Republicans had two options to prod their party members to vote.

One was…to pull months of punches and put happy faces on the combative GOP challengers seeking to unseat the state’s Democratic governor and U.S. senator. The other was to try to scare the bajeezus out of voters.

They’ve chosen the latter.

“Vote like your life depends on it,” reads a recent mailer authorized by Republican U.S. Senate candidate Cory Gardner’s campaign. It features a shadowy picture of four faceless jihadists-looking-types brandishing guns. [Pols emphasis]

Then there’s the $3.5 million TV ad by crisis creator Karl Rove’s political spin-machine Crossroads GPS attacking U.S. Sen. Mark Udall’s national security credentials. It stars a 30-something woman identified only as “Melissa, mother of five,” sitting on somebody’s American dreamy front porch holding an iPad…

National security has traditionally been a strong point for Sen. Udall, both from his time in the U.S. House and in the Senate. Udall serves on the Armed Services Committee and the Select Committee on Intelligence, and generally has a voting record that voters like: Udall voted against the Iraq war, but has voted to support troops in the field with appropriations unlike many other Democrats. Udall's high profile on issues like National Security Agency domestic surveillance and the Senate's battle with the Central Intelligence Agency over interrogation policy, long before this election, give Udall credibility as he positions himself at odds with the Obama administration.

So naturally, knocking Udall down on this core issue is a big priority for the GOP.

Bob Beauprez.

The hit on Udall over foreign policy in the latter stages of the campaign has made use of the two most popular foreign policy scare stories in circulation nationally: the Ebola outbreak in West Africa and the Islamic State in Iraq and Syria (ISIS). We talked last week about Gardner's highly misleading comments about Ebola in a recent debate, refuted strongly by Politifact. Likewise, Factcheck.org notes that the attacks on Udall over ISIS from Crossroads GPS, originating in an out-of-context quote from a debate last summer, have little basis in reality:

Udall didn’t dismiss ISIL as nothing to worry about. Instead, he said the terrorist group wasn’t an “imminent” threat to the U.S. but will be in the future if the country doesn’t respond in the Middle East now.

This isn’t the only attack ad to pick up on the Udall quote. The NRSC highlighted it in an ad also portraying Udall as soft on terrorism, as did Udall’s Republican opponent, Rep. Cory Gardner.

But the Crossroads ad is the only one to actually cite a news article that supports what Udall said. While the woman in the ad says, “As a mom and a Marine, I know the danger is closer to home than Sen. Udall seems to think,” an on-screen graphic cites an August USA Today article headlined, “Returning Islamic State fighters could threaten USA.” That article quotes experts saying that an attack on U.S. soil isn’t an imminent threat, but there’s concern about what could happen if fighters holding Western passports return home.

In the Colorado gubernatorial race, the big story over the weekend was the blowback against GOP candidate Bob Beauprez for his factually-challenged misuse of the murder of the director of the Colorado Department of Corrections last year in campaign ads–ads that became toxic after the widow of director Tom Clements told Beauprez to stop falsely politicizing her husband's murder. There is a common theme between Beauprez's untruthful attack on Hickenlooper over Clements' murder and the misleading attacks on Sen. Udall over national security.

The common theme is a willingness to lie to people in order to scare them. It's not our purpose to rule on whether this is an effective tactic, as in the right circumstances it surely can be–but it does generally occur for certain reasons. We'll leave it to our readers to discuss in this case what those may be.

18 thoughts on “Argumentum in Terrorem: Gardner, Beauprez Appeal To Fear”

MichaelBowman says:

October 27, 2014 at 11:41 am

…a sure sign that your internals suggest the numbers aren't moving in your favor.

Log in to Reply
FrankUnderwood says:

October 27, 2014 at 11:50 am

Campaign strategy 101 tells candidates not to go negative at the end of the race. Both Ways really has no choice but the Hail Mary pass. As for Whory, you may be right. Things may be getting uncomfortably close.

As for the substance of their strategy, does anyone recall who was in charge on 9/11? Anyone recall who mistakenly invaded Iraq looking for WMDs? Anyone remember who promised to smoke out Osama bin Laden? Anyone remember who actually got OBL?

Log in to Reply
1. MichaelBowman says:
  
  October 27, 2014 at 11:59 am
  
  The only real threats to families in Gardner's district are his votes against a raise in the minimum wage and his Democrat-foiled attempt to gut food assistance. (his district is home to over 100,000 children living in poverty).
  
  Log in to Reply
debbielynnepaint says:

October 27, 2014 at 11:51 am

I sure hope you are right, Michael. I told my husband this morning that I couldn't stand looking at Con Man Gardner's face for 6 years.

Log in to Reply
Conserv. Head Banger says:

October 27, 2014 at 11:59 am

I believe that the ad with "Melissa" also identifies her as a marine. Fact check anyone?

Log in to Reply
1. FrankUnderwood says:
  
  October 27, 2014 at 12:45 pm
  
  She mentioned she was a "mother and a marine." But unlike a certain Republican Congressman who will remain nameless, she did not wear her uniform in the commercial.
  
  Log in to Reply
DawnPatrol says:

October 27, 2014 at 12:02 pm

I loathe that nasty shill woman in the Con Man vid above. MAle GOTPers really do think women are fundamentally stupid and easily misled/manipulated by swaggering, macho behavior, and that they're unable to see through transparent partisan hackery like this garbage advertisement.

Most non-Stepford GOTP women seen right through your deception, GOTP. Remember: Female voters were the biggest detractors of your beloved Snowbank Snooki (aka Sarah "Gotta Get to Gucci's with the Rubes' Donations" Palin.)

Log in to Reply
1. FrankUnderwood says:
  
  October 27, 2014 at 12:46 pm
  
  Thank you for Snowbank Snooki. I've been looking for a new appellation for Caribou Barbie for some time now.
  
  Log in to Reply
Big Time says:

October 27, 2014 at 12:03 pm

This is a Red Alert to all GOPers: "Oh, shit! We are losing, get your asses to the polls!! We've lost on the issues, we are falling back to making people crap their pants – not sure if that will get them to the polls, but we've got nothing left."

Log in to Reply
Diogenesdemar says:

October 27, 2014 at 12:14 pm

The scariest thing in Colorado right now is these two idiot tools . . .

. . . Boopray and Craven (not Moderatus and that other assworm).

Log in to Reply
Big Time says:

October 27, 2014 at 12:37 pm

Who is the real Cory Gardner? His supporters say he has been spotted hiking in the Rocky Mountains and they filmed him for a campaign ad … but no one has been able to confirm his position on Personhood or whether he voted for Dems and might in fact be a secret Dem and will switch back to the party he first registered and campaigned for in the 1990s … there have been rumors of sightings for years, but no one has been able to confirm who the real Cory Gardner is ….

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bigfoot

Log in to Reply
OrangeFree says:

October 27, 2014 at 12:43 pm

I remember that women from a previous ad. She wasn't a marine back in that one like she is now.

Protip: use different actors

Log in to Reply
1. FrankUnderwood says:
  
  October 27, 2014 at 12:47 pm
  
  So she's as genuine as some of Mitch McConnell's enthusiastic supporters who were hired and brought in from out of state?
  
  Log in to Reply
  1. MichaelBowman says:
    
    October 27, 2014 at 12:51 pm
    
    She's as authentic as the ex-Allard staffer posing as an ordinary rancher, promising us she'ss "investigated" fracking and assures us that it's safe .
    
    Log in to Reply
    1. mamajama55 says:
      
      October 27, 2014 at 1:01 pm
      
      I understand that the Friendly Farmer in the anti-Prop 105 ad is also a lobbyist.
      
      Log in to Reply
      1. MichaelBowman says:
        
        October 27, 2014 at 1:09 pm
        
        Oops…
        
        Log in to Reply
oobapooba says:

October 27, 2014 at 9:04 pm

Seriously doubt that a U.S. Marine would say such a thing about ISIS/ISIL (whatever) in Udall context. (Gardner, certainly; Republican foreign policy being what it is). See my other comments re ISIS.

Had family member in combat in Iraq, in '04 called every single person on earth that he knew, told them to vote for Kerry because Dubya didn't know what he was doing (surprise), and that everyone there was voting for Kerry to end what they called Operation Iraqi Liberation. This not reported by liberal media, of course.

The ad is an obvious crock.

Log in to Reply
ScottP says:

October 28, 2014 at 4:52 am

As a father, a former Marine and a law enforcement dispatcher with 9 years of experience, I call bullshit!

If your scared for your kid's future because Udall isn't pissing his pants over ISIL then you're a dumbass. Unless a U.S. Senator does something over the top, they are going to have very little impact on local public safety.

Log in to Reply